Comparing SMILE, Contoura Vision & LASIK Surgery: Know Which One Is Best For You!

We know, that when it comes to saying goodbye to glasses and contacts, there are a lot of options to consider. With all of the different types of vision correction surgery available, it can be hard to know which one is right for you. But don’t worry, we’re here to help you! Let’s compare three of the most popular vision correction surgeries: LASIK vs SMILE vs Contoura Vision, and find out which is right for you. So, let’s get started!

Understanding the Basics: LASIK, SMILE, and Contoura Vision

In the realm of vision correction surgeries, LASIK, SMILE, and Contoura Vision stand out as popular options, each with its unique approach to providing clear vision. Let’s delve into the fundamental principles of each procedure to offer readers a comprehensive understanding of how they work.

LASIK: Laser-Assisted Situ Keratomileusis

LASIK is a proven and safe surgical method designed for vision correction and the reduction or elimination of dependence on glasses or contact lenses. This procedure is particularly effective in addressing common refractive errors such as Myopia, Hyperopia, and Astigmatism.

The LASIK process unfolds in a series of precise steps:

• Corneal Flap Creation
  The surgeon uses a microkeratome to form a thin, hinged corneal flap.
• Exposure to Corneal Tissue
  The created flap is gently lifted to reveal the underlying corneal tissue.
• Laser Reshaping
  An excimer laser is employed to reshape the cornea according to a predetermined pattern, correcting refractive errors.
• Flap Repositioning
  The corneal flap is meticulously placed back onto the treated area without the need for stitches.

Remarkably, LASIK surgery typically takes around 20 minutes, offering a swift and efficient method for vision correction.

SMILE: Small Incision Lenticule Extraction

SMILE distinguishes itself with a minimally invasive and virtually painless approach to vision correction. This technique utilizes a single femtosecond laser to create a small lenticule, which is extracted through a tiny incision, resulting in improved vision.

The concise steps of SMILE surgery include:

• Anesthesia and Lid Placement
  Eye drops are administered for anesthesia, and a speculum is placed on the lids to maintain the eye’s open position.
• Lenticule Creation
  The femtosecond laser precisely forms a lenticular, a thin circular piece of tissue.
• Lenticule Extraction
  The surgeon gently separates and removes the lenticular through the small incision, achieving vision correction.

Notably, SMILE surgery boasts a quick duration of 5-10 minutes, making it an attractive option for those seeking a swift recovery.

Contoura Vision: Laser Vision Correction with Precision

Contoura Vision, a form of Laser Vision Correction, goes beyond addressing refractive errors; it also corrects corneal irregularities, providing unmatched visual clarity. The Contoura topography-guided LASIK procedure involves meticulous steps:

• Topography Measurement
  Using a topographer, the surgeon takes thousands of measurements across the cornea, creating a detailed map.
• Correction of Irregularities
  The topographer corrects corneal irregularities by making 22,000 unique elevation points, resulting in a perfectly smooth corneal surface.
• Visual Axis Treatment
  Contoura Vision is performed on the visual axis, aligning with the natural axis of sight for optimal visual outcomes.

In essence, Contoura Vision combines precise measurements and correction, enhancing visual quality and offering a unique approach to laser vision correction.

Contoura Vision vs LASIK vs SMILE: Comprehensive Comparison

When it comes to choosing the right vision correction procedure, understanding the nuances of different surgeries is crucial. Let’s delve into a detailed comparison of Contoura Vision, LASIK, and SMILE, evaluating various factors to help you make an informed decision tailored to your vision correction needs.

 

Factors	Contoura Vision	LASIK	SMILE
Quality of Vision	Sharpest vision possible (beyond 6/6 vision)	Clear Vision, normal vision	Clear Vision, normal vision
Safety	US – FDA-certified	US – FDA-certified	US – FDA-certified
Technology	Femto Laser + Excimer Laser + Topolyzer	Femto Laser + Excimer Laser	Only Femto Laser
Painless	Painless	Painless	Painless
Post Surgery Dryness	No Dryness	Mild dryness	Mild dryness
Tissue Saving & Corneal Strength	Secures maximum corneal tissue (12-15 microns)	12-15 microns of corneal tissue	35-45 microns of corneal tissue
Recovery	Immediate visual recovery (WOW effect)	Fast recovery	7-10 days to see clearly
Re-treatment	Possible	Possible	Very difficult
Range of Correction	Corrects almost all types of Refractive Errors	Myopia (Nearsightedness) and Hyperopia (Farsightedness) and cylinder powers	Myopia (Nearsightedness) only
Eye Movement Tracking	Fastest eye tracker	Can track eye movement	Tracking feature is missing in the SMILE machine
Visual Axis Treatment	Directed towards the Visual Axis, providing much sharper visual outcomes	Bladeless LASIK and SMILE treat on pupillary axis, missing on supervision effect	Bladeless LASIK and SMILE treat on pupillary axis, missing on supervision effect
Corneal Irregularities Correction	Irregularities of the cornea are smoothed	Correction of corneal irregularities missing in Bladeless LASIK and SMILE	Correction of corneal irregularities missing in Bladeless LASIK and SMILE

In conclusion, the choice between Contoura Vision, LASIK, and SMILE depends on various factors. Each procedure has its strengths, and this comprehensive comparison aims to empower you with the information needed to make a well-informed decision for achieving optimal visual clarity.

Cost Comparison: Contoura Vision vs LASIK vs SMILE

When considering vision correction surgeries, understanding the associated costs is a crucial aspect. The expense of LASIK, SMILE, and Contoura Vision procedures can vary significantly based on factors such as technology, expertise, and the complexity of each case. Let’s delve into a detailed cost comparison to help you make an informed decision.

• LASIK Eye Surgery:
  • Standard Blade LASIK: Starting at ₹15,000.
  • Bladeless LASIK in Delhi: Varies between ₹75,000 and ₹90,000 (approx.).

  The cost of LASIK procedures depends on the level of technology utilized, with Bladeless LASIK being a more advanced and therefore a higher-cost option.

• SMILE Eye Surgery:
  • The cost is approximately Rs. 1,00,000.

  SMILE surgery, while offering a minimally invasive approach, comes with a moderate cost, making it an attractive option for those seeking precise vision correction.

• Contoura Vision Laser Surgery: Offered at Eyemantra Hospital, the cost ranges between ₹95,000 and ₹1,15,000 (approx.)

Contoura Vision, being an advanced LASIK surgery, incorporates cutting-edge technology and requires specialized equipment. The cost also encompasses the expertise and education of the ophthalmologist performing the procedure.

While cost is a significant consideration, it’s essential to weigh it against the benefits and precision each procedure offers. Ultimately, consulting with eye care professionals and understanding the specific factors influencing costs will aid in making an informed decision tailored to your vision correction needs.

Benefits

LASIK Surgery

LASIK surgery offers a safe and effective solution for various vision problems, providing several notable benefits:

• Long-lasting Results: LASIK delivers enduring improvement in a patient’s eyesight.
• Improved Looks without Glasses: Patients can enjoy an enhanced appearance without the need for glasses.
• Freedom from Spectacles/Contact Lenses: LASIK eliminates the dependence on spectacles or contact lenses.
• Painless, Bladeless, and Safe: The procedure is painless, and bladeless, and has received approval from the US FDA.
• Quick Recovery: Patients can return to their normal schedules within a day after surgery.
• Immediate Vision Improvement: Vision is often improved almost immediately after the surgery.
• No Dressings or Stitches: LASIK does not require dressings or stitches, contributing to a hassle-free recovery.

Contoura Vision

Contoura Vision, an advanced version of LASIK, offers unique advantages for vision correction:

• Safest Procedure for Specs Removal: Contoura Vision is considered one of the safest procedures for removing spectacles, involving no blades, cuts, injections, or hospitalization.
• Removal of Corneal Irregularities: With a special Topolyzer, Contoura Vision can map and remove corneal irregularities, resulting in a perfectly smooth corneal surface and enhanced visual sharpness.
• Visual Axis Treatment: Contoura Vision specifically treats the visual axis, the natural seeing axis of the eye, contributing to improved visual quality.
• Suitable for Most People: It is a versatile procedure suitable for a wide range of individuals seeking vision correction.
• No Dry Eyes: Contoura Vision is associated with minimal or no dry eye issues post-surgery.
• No Flap Issues: Unlike traditional LASIK, Contoura Vision does not involve creating a corneal flap, eliminating concerns related to flap complications.

SMILE Surgery

SMILE surgery, a minimally invasive form of laser eye surgery, offers its own set of advantages:

• Quick Procedure: The surgery typically takes 20-30 minutes, offering a swift vision correction option.
• Speedy Recovery: Patients often experience fast outcomes, with significant improvement within the first few hours, reaching maximum improvement within a few weeks.
• No Hospitalization or Bandages: SMILE is characterized by a walk-in, walk-out approach, requiring no hospitalization or bandages.
• Treats Pupillary Axis: SMILE treats the pupillary axis, making it a suitable option for those ineligible for other forms of surgery.

In conclusion, the choice among LASIK, Contoura Vision, and SMILE depends on individual preferences, specific visual needs, and desired outcomes. Each procedure offers unique benefits, allowing patients to choose the one that aligns best with their vision correction goals.

Suitability and Eligibility Criteria

LASIK Surgery: To be considered a suitable candidate for LASIK, individuals typically need to meet the following criteria:

• Age: Over 18 years old.
• Corneal Thickness: The thickness of the cornea is a critical factor to ensure there is enough tissue for the procedure.
• Eye Health: Good overall eye health is essential.
• Refractive Error: LASIK is effective for correcting myopia (nearsightedness), hyperopia (farsightedness), and astigmatism.

It’s important to note that a comprehensive eye examination by an experienced eye care professional is necessary to determine eligibility for LASIK. Read More: Discover the Essential Tests Required Before LASIK

Contoura Vision: Contoura Vision is not suitable for all patients, and eligibility criteria include:

• Thorough Eye Exam: A detailed eye examination and health history are conducted to ensure the patient will benefit from the procedure.
• Stable Vision: Candidates should have stable vision for at least 12 to 24 months before undergoing Contoura Vision.

Individuals interested in Contoura Vision should consult with their eye care provider for a thorough assessment to determine eligibility.

SMILE Surgery: SMILE surgery is suitable for a specific range of myopia and has additional considerations:

• Myopia Range: Typically, candidates should have a myopic prescription in the range of -1 to -8 diopters.
• Exclusions: Some conditions may make individuals less suitable candidates, such as nursing or being pregnant, farsightedness, thin corneas, and keratoconus.

Similar to other procedures, a detailed examination is necessary to determine eligibility for SMILE surgery.

General Note: Regardless of the chosen surgery – LASIK, Contoura Vision, or SMILE – it is imperative to undergo specific tests to assess eligibility. Individuals interested in determining their eligibility can book a free check-up or contact the eye care provider at the provided number: +91-9711116605.

Conclusion

In wrapping up our discussion on Contoura vision vs LASIK vs SMILE, we’ve shared important details to help you make smart choices for your eyes. But here’s the key – no matter which surgery you’re considering, it all boils down to whether it’s the right fit for you.

Therefore, your eligibility is the game-changer. The best surgery for your eyes depends on your needs and health. So, before you decide, make sure you get those crucial tests done.

Ready for LASIK Surgery? See Clearly with EyeMantra!

So, if you’re dreaming of life without glasses, LASIK surgery at EyeMantra can make it a reality. Book your free appointment now by calling +91-9711116605.