Choosing Between ICL Surgery vs PRK: What You Need to Know

ICL surgery vs PRK

Tired of those glasses? You’re not alone. With advancements in eye surgeries, the dream of clear vision without spectacles is now a reality for many. But with options like ICL Surgery and PRK vying for your attention, which one should you lean towards? In this guide, we’ll unpack the nitty-gritty of  ICL Surgery vs PRK. From understanding their basics, weighing the costs, to diving into real patient experiences – by the end, you’ll have a clearer sight, not just literally, but also on which procedure stands out for your unique needs. Ready to see the bigger picture? Let’s jump right in!

Understanding the Basics: ICL vs PRK

Glasses and contact lenses have long been our go-to solutions for vision correction. But the realm of eye surgeries has been evolving rapidly, offering more permanent solutions. Among them, ICL (Implantable Collamer Lens) and PRK (Photorefractive Keratectomy) have emerged as popular choices. Let’s break down the basics of each.

  • ICL (Implantable Collamer Lens) Surgery: Imagine having a contact lens, but instead of placing it on the surface of your eye every day, it’s implanted inside your eye! That’s essentially what ICL is about. In this procedure, a thin, biocompatible lens is placed between the iris (the colored part of the eye) and the natural lens. This lens aids in focusing light onto the retina, thus correcting vision. The biggest advantage? There’s no removal of any eye tissue, making it a reversible procedure.
  • PRK (Photorefractive Keratectomy): Now, PRK is a tad different. Instead of adding a lens, PRK reshapes the cornea (the front surface of the eye) using a precise laser. By delicately removing a thin layer of the corneal tissue, the way light enters the eye is altered, ensuring it focuses accurately onto the retina. One key thing to remember about PRK is that there’s no flap creation, unlike other laser surgeries like LASIK.

Choosing between ICL and PRK essentially boils down to understanding these foundational differences and then aligning them with individual needs and suitability. As we dive deeper, we’ll explore more nuances to help you make an informed choice.

The Aspect Of Safety and Invasiveness Of Both The Surgeries 

The Aspect Of Safety and Invasiveness Of Both The SurgeriesWhen it comes to any surgical procedure, safety is paramount. Let’s dissect the safety aspects of both ICL and PRK, laying out the facts in a digestible manner.

ICL (Implantable Collamer Lens):

  • Invasiveness: While ICL is termed minimally invasive, it does require a small incision to insert the lens. However, this incision is tiny and usually heals quickly.
  • Safety Profile: ICL has been in use for years and has an impressive safety track record. Most complications are rare, and the procedure itself is reversible.
  • Aftercare: Post-surgery, patients might need to use certain eye drops for a while, and routine check-ups are advised.

PRK (Photorefractive Keratectomy):

  • Invasiveness: PRK stands out as non-invasive. It doesn’t involve flap creation or any incisions. The laser simply reshapes the cornea’s surface.
  • Safety Profile: Like ICL, PRK has been around for decades and is known for its safety. While the initial recovery might take a bit longer than other laser surgeries, the results are reliable.
  • Aftercare: After PRK, protective contact lenses are usually placed on the eyes for a few days to aid healing. Regular check-ups and eye drops are part of the aftercare routine.

In essence, both ICL and PRK come with their own sets of advantages and require different post-operative care. However, both have stood the test of time in terms of safety and effectiveness.

Recovery Time: What to Expect Post-Surgery

Recovery Time-What to Expect Post-SurgeryOne of the most common concerns people have before undergoing any surgical procedure is the duration of recovery. How soon can you get back to your routine? Let’s break down the recovery timelines for both ICL and PRK.


ICL (Implantable Collamer Lens):

  • Immediate Aftermath: Post-ICL surgery, many patients experience instant clarity, with vision steadily improving in the hours following the procedure.
  • Full Recovery: Typically, ICL patients can resume most of their day-to-day activities within 24 hours. However, strenuous exercises and activities that strain the eyes might need to be avoided for a short while.
  • Follow-ups: Regular post-operative check-ups are crucial in the first week to ensure the eyes are healing correctly.

PRK (Photorefractive Keratectomy):

  • Immediate Aftermath: The initial recovery from PRK is slower than ICL. While some clarity might be noticed right after the surgery, the vision tends to fluctuate for a few days.
  • Full Recovery: Most PRK patients experience stabilized vision within 1-2 weeks post-surgery. However, it’s not uncommon for optimal vision clarity to be achieved after a few weeks or even months.
  • Follow-ups: After PRK, more frequent check-ups might be required, especially in the first month, to monitor the healing process.

In summary, while ICL offers a quicker bounce back, PRK demands a tad more patience. But regardless of the timeline, both surgeries aim for the same result: clearer vision and a life less dependent on corrective eyewear.

Cost Analysis: Investment in Clear Vision

Making a decision between ICL and PRK isn’t just about understanding the procedures; it’s also about weighing the financial aspects. Let’s take a closer look at the cost breakdown for both surgeries.

FactorICL (Implantable Collamer Lens)PRK (Photorefractive Keratectomy)
Initial Surgery CostTypically starting from 45,000 (per eye)Starts around 18,000 (per eye)
Follow-up AppointmentsFewer, thus might be less costlyMore frequent, could cost slightly more
Post-Surgery MedicationsStandard eye drops and medications, usually included in initial costMight require specific eye drops for longer, potentially adding to cost
Potential Future TreatmentsLess likely due to its adaptability, meaning fewer long-term costsSome patients might need touch-up procedures, adding to the long-term cost
MaintenanceAlmost negligible, given the durability of the lensPeriodic check-ups might add to the overall cost over the years

While the initial investment for ICL might seem higher, it’s essential to consider the long-term benefits, including fewer follow-ups and potential savings from not needing future treatments. On the other hand, PRK, though more economical upfront, could involve additional costs over the years. Always consult with your ophthalmologist to get a detailed cost breakdown tailored to your specific needs.

Outcome and Quality of Vision

When it comes to any vision correction procedure, the ultimate goal is clear and improved eyesight. Both ICL and PRK surgeries promise better vision, but how do they compare in terms of outcomes and the quality of vision achieved? Let’s delve into a comparative analysis.

  • Sharpness of Vision:
    • ICL: The ICL surgery often results in a sharper, more defined vision, especially for those with high myopia. The implanted lens provides a natural-feeling correction, mimicking the eye’s inherent functioning.
    • PRK: PRK surgery reshapes the cornea, resulting in improved vision. However, it might not always match the sharpness achieved by ICL, particularly for those with very high prescriptions.
  • Night Vision:
    • ICL: One advantage of ICL is better nighttime vision. Fewer complaints are recorded about halos or glare around lights at night, making night driving and other activities more comfortable.
    • PRK: Some PRK patients report issues with nighttime vision, especially shortly after the surgery. Halos or glares around lights might be a temporary side effect that usually improves over time.
  • Overall Patient Satisfaction:
    • ICL: Most patients who undergo ICL surgery report high satisfaction rates, given the swift recovery time and the quality of vision achieved. The adaptability of the lens and the natural feel it offers add to the satisfaction.
    • PRK: PRK also has high satisfaction rates, especially for those who weren’t candidates for other vision correction surgeries. The longer recovery time might be a drawback for some, but the end results in terms of vision clarity make it worthwhile for many.

In conclusion, while both ICL and PRK promise improved vision, the choice between them often boils down to individual needs, eye health conditions, and personal preferences.

Determining Candidacy: Who Should Opt for Which?

Choosing the right vision correction surgery isn’t a one-size-fits-all decision. Several factors determine an individual’s suitability for either ICL or PRK. Let’s explore these factors to provide clarity on which surgery might be best suited for whom:

Corneal ThicknessSuitable for those with thin or irregular corneas as it doesn’t involve the cornea directly.Works for those with thinner corneas but has a minimum thickness requirement since it reshapes the cornea.
Severity of Refractive ErrorsBeneficial for high myopia, up to -20 dioptres.Can treat a wide range but may not be ideal for extremely high myopia or hyperopia.
Eye Health & Previous SurgeriesIdeal if no internal eye conditions or complications from previous surgeries.Preferred for those who’ve had surgeries or conditions making flap surgeries riskier, as it’s a surface procedure.
Age FactorRecommended for individuals aged 21 and above with a stable prescription.Considered for adults over 18 with a stable prescription for at least a year.

Both ICL and PRK surgeries have unique advantages. The choice largely depends on individual eye health, prescription, age, and specific needs. Always consult an eye specialist for a thorough examination and personalized advice.


In the realm of vision correction, both ICL and PRK stand tall with their unique advantages. The journey to a life without glasses or contacts begins with understanding your options and choosing the one that aligns with your unique needs. Whether you’re inclined towards ICL’s rapid recovery or PRK’s non-invasive approach, it’s crucial to get expert advice. The decision to enhance your vision is momentous, but the right guidance can make it effortless.

Are you considering ICL surgery? Don’t wait to embark on your journey towards crystal clear vision. Experience unparalleled clarity with ICL Surgery at EyeMantra. Ready to see the world more vividly? Book your free appointment now at 9711116605.

Make An Appointment

Free Tele-Consultation

Book Appointment or Video Consultation online with top eye doctors